Which option describes a valid method for testing the necessity of a premise in an argument?

Providing additional evidence that directly supports the conclusion.

Rewriting the conclusion.

Considering whether the argument would still hold if this premise were removed.

Testing whether a premise is necessary means asking what would happen to the argument if that premise were removed. A premise is necessary if taking it away would cause the conclusion to no longer follow; if the conclusion still follows without it, the premise isn’t required.

This approach directly checks whether the premise plays a crucial role in supporting the conclusion. If removing it makes the argument fail, that premise is essential to the reasoning.

Adding more evidence that supports the conclusion doesn't test necessity; it strengthens the argument. Rewriting the conclusion changes what is being proved, not whether a premise is needed. Quoting unrelated data is irrelevant to whether the premise is required for the conclusion.

Quoting unrelated data.

Want more questions?

All options are one-time payments.

$25.99

30 day pass for new members

All the basics to get you started

  • Ad-free experience
  • View your previous attempt history
  • Mobile app access
  • In-depth explanations
  • 30 day premium pass access
$59.99$171.99 usd

6 month DELUXE pass (most popular)

Full access FOR 6 MONTHS! & the ultimate digital PDF study guide (BONUS)

  • $171.99 usd value for $59.99! You save $106!
  • Ad-free experience
  • View your previous attempt history
  • Mobile app access
  • In-depth explanations
  • 6 months of full access
  • Ultimate digital PDF study guide included
  • Priority support
$15.99 $24.99

Ultimate digital PDF study guide

For those that prefer a more traditional form of learning

  • Available for instant download
  • Available offline
  • Hundreds of practice multiple choice questions
  • Comprehensive content
  • Detailed explanations
Image Description
Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy